Text: Karin Clavel
What is Mendeley?
Mendeley is a (free) web service for online reference management & reference sharing. With Mendeley you can easily store references to papers, books or even websites. You can work with the web-based version, which comes with a handy bookmarklet to instantly add references to your Mendeley Library without typing. Alternatively, you can install Mendeley Desktop and add references by simply dragging and dropping PDFs. You could also create a watch folder; any PDF added to the watch folder will be imported into your library.
The references and even the PDFs can be backed up online, with 1GB storage for free. This also allows you to access your library from any computer and even from your iPhone or iPad. If the storage is not enough, you can move to a paid premium account, or you could set up Dropbox as your storage file.
Mendeley automatically fills in important information, such as authors, titles, journal, abstract, keywords and also the URL or the full text PDF.
Collaboration and academic networking
You can create a public or private group and invite the people you work with to share your references, but also annotations, tags and notes. The service will keep track of the activity within the group. You can join existing public groups and get in contact with people with a similar research interest worldwide.
Based on your profile and your own publications, Mendeley suggests new contacts. Just like any other social network, you can be as anonymous or as public as you choose.
Searching with Papers
You can also search the “Papers” catalogue with (references to) over 30 million papers. Add TU Delft Library’s link resolver as library access link (My Account -> Sharing / Importing > Add library manually: http://sfx.tudelft.nl:8888/sfx_local) and quickly find the full text, if we have it.
What is good about it?
The most useful feature for me is having all the PDFs in one place where you can search, sort and tag, but also add notes and highlights. With the highlight tool, I can mark the interesting bits & pieces, so when I come back to the paper, I can easily skip to the highlighted parts. I also like the fact that when I read a long thesis in Mendeley, it automatically remembers where I was when I can’t finish it in one go.
I like the way you can let Mendeley change the filenames of your PDFs in something meaningful.
Any downsides?
Yes, unfortunately. I did not get the Cite While You Write functionality to work on my Mac.
The iPhone app crashes a lot, especially when accessing a group folder.
Something else I don’t quite get is the Dashboard. It shows some (group) activity, but not all of it. ?? (check NL versie)
Is it for me?
If you are not using a reference management tool now, you should give Mendeley a try. Also, if you are unsatisfied with other reference management software such as EndNote (web) or Reference Manager, take a moment to set up an account and import your references and see how you like it (and tell me about it using the comments option below).
Do you have a large, unstructured collection of PDFs? Try putting them in a watch folder and see if you can use Mendeley to organise the bulk.
Mendeley supports co-discovery, co-reading and co-annotation, but it does not support co-writing. If you are looking for a collaborative environment to write papers, Google Docs or Sharepoint might fit the bill.
Compatibility
The desktop software is available for Mac, Windows and Linux. There are plugins for creating citations in MS Word and Open Office. Import works for BibTeX, RIS and EndNote™ XML files.
Alternatives
Zotero used to be only a Firefox plugin, but has a beta desktop version out, also targeting group use. EndNote and the still somewhat old-fashioned looking Reference Manager, both by Thomson Reuters are available for free for TU Delft students and staff from the software distribution server on Blackboard. Papers and Sente are much liked but paid tools and for Mac only. For an extensive comparison, see: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_reference_management_software
Let us know!
Have you tried Mendeley? Please leave a comment with your experience.
Inmiddels gebruik ik al een tijdje Mendeley op mijn Mac, maar heb nu alsnog besloten volledig over te stappen naar ofwel Papers of Endnote voor de mac.
De redenen die voor mij doorslaggevend waren zijn alsvolgt:
1. Hoe groter de database met wetenschappelijke artikelen werd, hoe trager Mendeley. Uiteindelijk leidde dit tot onnodig vaak crashen van de applicatie en verschuiving van bronvermeldingen in mijn word-bestanden. Bovendien duurde het soms 30 sec tot 1 minuut om een bron te laden in mijn word-bestand.
2. Het verwijzen naar paginanummers in een citaat is tot op heden niet mogelijk. Met name wanneer er naar bepaalde passages in een boek verwezen moet worden is deze functionaliteit een vereiste.
3. Mendely kan niet/of gaat niet overweg met updates binnen Microsoft Office 2011 for Mac. Na een recente beveiligingsupdate werkt de word-plugin niet meer en kan ik mijn referenties handmatig gaan aanpassen.
Beste Paul,
Bedankt voor het delen van je ervaring. Ik heb gelukkig (nog?) geen last van performance problemen (met ongeveer 100 artikelen en rapporten in twee groepen), maar heb de Word-plugin nooit werkend gekregen. Ik gebruik “Copy Citation”. Ik blijf toch voorlopig met Mendeley werken, aangezien ik het toevoegen van documenten wel heel gemakkelijk vind, zeker vergeleken met EndNote. Mocht je willen overstappen op EndNote: de nieuwste versie X5 is beschikbaar via Blackboard. Met X5 is het nu mogelijk ook in EndNote Web de PDFs te koppelen. Eerst desktop software installeren, dan EndNote Web configureren… Export-import via RIS format werkt redelijk. Wat betreft Papers, ik weet dat er enthousiaste gebruikers zijn op de TU, maar ik heb er zelf (nog) geen ervaring mee. Groet, Karin
Laatst deze korte review achtergelaten op een andere blog. Ik raad Mendeley niet aan maar heb nu geen zin om over te stappen. Ik zou eerder Zotero of Papers uitproberen. EndNote heb ik geen ervaring mee. Readcube zou ook interessant kunnen zijn.
“I must say: I still very much dislike the desktop app. I think the alternatives have a much cleaner interface (Nature’s ReadCube) and some compelling features (Mekentosj Papers). In addition, I think that with several PDF’s opened (tabbed horizontally, another mistake I think) the application consumes a lot of memory and gets quite slow.
Despite all this, I do think that Mendeley is still a great app that helps me sort my papers, but it certainly can be improved a lot.”
Hallo, voor mijn thesis gebruik ik mendeley, maar nu wil ik de bronnen manueel aanpassen zodat ze perfect staan volgens APA. Wanneer ik dit in word doe en nadien een nieuwe bron toevoeg via mendeley verdwijnen mijn aanpassingen…